What is the best Brunch restaurant in Upper West Side?

Barney Greengrass is our top pick for Brunch restaurants in Upper West Side, scoring 8.6/10. Century-old sturgeon and lox specialist with true New York character.

Any insider tips for Barney Greengrass?

Sit inside rather than sidewalk tables to watch the counter show.

What should I order at Barney Greengrass?

Sturgeon and eggs, Nova and eggs, potato latkes.

When should I visit Barney Greengrass?

Early weekend mornings before the cramped room overfills.

Who should go to Barney Greengrass?

Smoked fish devotees who plan mornings around bagels.

Any insider tips for Maison Pickle?

Portions are huge; split mains and save room for 24-layer cake.

When should I visit Maison Pickle?

Prime weekend brunch or lively evening reservations with friends.

Who should go to Maison Pickle?

Groups and diners chasing indulgent, over-the-top comfort plates.

Any insider tips for Sarabeth's West?

Reserve ahead on weekends; walk-ins often face long waits.

What should I order at Sarabeth's West?

Smoked salmon Benedict, pancakes, seasonal waffle.

When should I visit Sarabeth's West?

Mid-morning on weekends or earlier weekday breakfasts.

Who should go to Sarabeth's West?

Brunch traditionalists planning a sit-down meal with company.

Any insider tips for Brunch?

Grab a counter seat if you’re solo—it’s usually the quickest option.

What should I order at Brunch?

Eggs with toast, pancakes, avocado toast with poached egg.

When should I visit Brunch?

Late mornings or early afternoons for steady but manageable flow.

Who should go to Brunch?

Locals wanting unfussy brunch without long waits.

Best Brunch Restaurants in Upper West Side (10024)

Q: What should I order at Maison Pickle?

Fried Chicken 'N' Toast, Classique Mac & Cheese, French Dip.

4 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: December 2025

Save

Our Top Pick

Barney Greengrass

Century-old sturgeon and lox specialist with true New York character.

Notable Picks

#1 Barney Greengrass

8.6

$ Upper West Side (Central)

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Quick Bites Champions

Barney Greengrass is a 1908-born appetizing institution where smoked sturgeon, Nova, and egg plates define a classic Upper West Side brunch. The cramped dining room and counter service draw regulars for bagels, latkes, and old-school hospitality that has earned James Beard recognition and generations of loyalty.

Must-Try Dishes: Sturgeon and scrambled eggs, Nova Scotia salmon with eggs, Potato latkes with smoked fish

What Makes it Special: Century-old sturgeon and lox specialist with true New York character.

View Full Review →

#2 Maison Pickle

8.5

$ Upper West Side (Central)

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Comfort Food Classics Trendy Table Hotspots Birthday & Celebration Central

Maison Pickle leans into maximalist American comfort, with towering French dips, fried chicken on challah toast, and over-the-top mac and cheese anchoring brunch. Locals treat it as a high-energy spot for big-plate weekends and group outings built around cocktails and crisp fries.

Must-Try Dishes: Fried Chicken 'N' Toast, Classique Mac & Cheese, French Dip Sandwich

What Makes it Special: Blowout American comfort food and cocktails served in big, shareable formats.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Sarabeth's West

7.6

$$$ Upper West Side (Central)

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Comfort Food Classics Family Friendly Favorites Group Dining Gatherings

Sarabeth’s West is the Upper West Side branch of the citywide brunch brand, known for pancakes, French toast, and eggs Benedict served in a bright, family-friendly space. It remains a reliable option for classic American brunch plates, especially for visitors and families who prioritize familiar dishes over experimentation.

Must-Try Dishes: Smoked salmon eggs Benedict, Buttermilk pancakes, Pumpkin waffle

What Makes it Special: Longstanding full-service brunch spot known for Benedicts and baked goods.

View Full Review →

#4 Brunch

7.6

$$ Upper West Side (Central)

Vibes: Brunch Bliss Spots Cheap Eats Budget Brilliance Quick Bites Champions Solo Dining Sanctuaries

Brunch is a compact counter-service café on Broadway focused on all-day breakfast plates, sandwiches, and coffee. With fewer crowds than the marquee spots, it serves as a low-key neighborhood option when you want straightforward eggs and pancakes without a long wait.

Must-Try Dishes: Two Eggs Any Style with Toast, Buttermilk Pancakes, Avocado Toast with Poached Egg

What Makes it Special: Casual Broadway counter turning out straightforward breakfast plates and coffee.

View Full Review →