What is the best Seafood restaurant in Chelsea?

Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar is our top pick for Seafood restaurants in Chelsea, scoring 8.5/10. Raw‑bar depth and fresh seafood from a top NYC market.

Any insider tips for Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar?

Hit the half‑price oyster happy hour (Mon–Fri, 4–6 pm).

What should I order at Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar?

Oysters sampler, lobster roll, diver scallops.

When should I visit Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar?

Weeknight dinner or weekend lunch.

Who should go to Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar?

Oyster lovers and seafood diners seeking variety.

Any insider tips for The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Get the daily oyster special for an extra treat!

When should I visit The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Evenings for a romantic dinner.

Who should go to The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Seafood lovers and date night seekers.

Any insider tips for Seamore’s Chelsea?

Happy hour deals on oysters and drinks (Mon–Fri, 3–6 pm).

What should I order at Seamore’s Chelsea?

Fish tacos, lobster roll, monkfish sandwich.

Who should go to Seamore’s Chelsea?

Casual diners, lunch‑hour eaters, budget‑conscious seafood fans.

Best Seafood Restaurants in Chelsea (10011)

Q: What should I order at The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea?

Lobster roll, oysters, clam chowder.

3 hand-picked restaurants, critic-reviewed and ranked

Last Updated: May 2026

Save

Our Top Pick

Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar

Raw‑bar depth and fresh seafood from a top NYC market.

Notable Picks

#1 Cull & Pistol Oyster Bar

8.5

$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Date Night Magic Group Dining Gatherings Trendy Table Hotspots

A raw‑bar‑focused seafood hall inside Chelsea Market serving dozens of oyster varieties, lobster rolls, and seasonal seafood in a lively, casual‑elegant setting. Locals and visitors choose it for fresh catch and reliable execution. The menu balances approachable dishes (fish & chips) and premium items (uni, diver scallops).

Must-Try Dishes: Dozen East Coast Oysters, Connecticut-style Lobster Roll, Live Diver Scallops

What Makes it Special: Raw‑bar depth and fresh seafood from a top NYC market.

View Full Review →

#2 The Mermaid Inn - Chelsea

8.5

$$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Date Night Magic Comfort Food Classics Rooftop Views Revelry

An upscale seafood joint offering fresh oysters, lobster rolls, and a cozy bar.

Must-Try Dishes: Lobster Roll, Oysters, Clam Chowder

What Makes it Special: Fresh seafood with a cozy, upscale ambiance.

View Full Review →

Worthy Picks

#3 Seamore’s Chelsea

7.8

$$ Chelsea

Vibes: Trendy Table Hotspots Comfort Food Classics

Bright, beach‑inspired spot offering sustainable seafood — from fish tacos to lobster rolls — with a casual, friendly vibe ideal for lunch or informal dinner. The menu caters to varied dietary preferences while keeping seafood fresh and portioned well. It’s a go‑to for affordable, fresh seafood without pretense.

Must-Try Dishes: Montauk Fish Tacos, Maine Lobster Roll, Blackened Monkfish Sandwich

What Makes it Special: Sustainable seafood with relaxed coastal vibe in Chelsea.

View Full Review →